Can’t a western just
be a western? Although the western was the
most lucrative and virile genre for decades, it largely petered out in the
late-‘70s/early-‘80s after it became really self-aware and basically ran out of
ways to evolve. There will always be an audience for ‘em, though, and some
continue to get made (The Unforgiven,
Open Range and The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford
being three important examples), unfortunately the few “westerns” that show up
in the multiplexes are mostly pseudo-westerns, where the genre itself is just
novelty dressing.
You’ve got Young Guns,
which is really a teen heartthrob action movie; Bad Girls, a Charlie’s Angels-in-the-old-west kinda story; Posse, a modern blaxploitation in the
old west tale; Back to the Future III,
a blockbuster sci-fi adventure-comedy; Wild,
Wild West, a blockbuster sci-fi action-comedy; and The Missing, Ron Howard’s supernatural mystery/drama set in the old
West, as some examples. Most of these films use the well-established clichés of
the genre, such as shoot-outs, horse chases or saloon fights, to give a spin to
a story that could otherwise be set modern day. And most of them are awful
because of it. (Back to the Future III
actually works pretty well because the story itself is actually about modern
technology in an old world, and it puts some pretty clever spins on the
juxtaposition.)
None of these movies are as bad as Jonah Hex, though. Being a bit of a fan of the comic book (which
ironically later became just Hex when
the character was transported into a futuristic post-apocalyptic setting –
mwah! Glavin!), I spat in the face of better judgment and went to see it in the
theatre. And, yes, I would’ve had a better time being kicked in the neck by a
horse. Currently, it’s got my vote for worst film of the year.
It’s terrible in many,many different ways: the dull
direction, the horrible editing that seems to smash two or three different,
separately shot, versions of the plot together, the gaping logic and character
inconsistencies, the unfinished-looking computer effects and the non-presence
of Megan Fox – despite
the glaring presence of the Megan Fox corset-boobs that
are attached to her. I could go on, but, in short, it rained creative horse
apples in the theatre that night. (With the exception of star Josh Brolin, who tried his darndest to sell the character, even with all that rubbery scar makeup on his face.)
What does need to be pointed out is the worst offense of
all: the pointless modernization of the story. If the Hex character, with his
standard Old West hero deadly aim, trusty horse and dog sidekick, plus – PLUS!
– his non-standard supernatural knack for communicating with the dead, dodging
bullets and surviving shotgun wounds, wasn’t powerful enough, some jackass
(maybe one of the screenwriters, maybe not) decided he needed super-weapons.
So, we see Hex level a town via the massive, fully
automated, dual Gatling guns mounted on his horse(!?!). Later, he buys grenade
launcher pistols. But, I guess it, like, only makes sense, seeing as the bad
guy (a very slumming John Malkovich) has a super-bomb he’s trying to destroy
the nation’s capital with – on July 4th no less!!! It’s a hilariously failed
attempt to modernize the story with a terrorism plot.
There are decades of Hex stories to draw upon, and no need
to toss in a bunch of contemporary gadgetry. At all. Y’see, there’s a level of
drama to the western genre in the whole man-vs.-nature/the dangerous frontier
theme, which is lost when you add weaponized horses and magic exploding
cannonballs [slaps head, shakes fist at sky]. There’s really nothing worse than
that kinda crap in a western, or in any period film, for that matter (e.g. Van Helsing).
The bigger issue, really, is that Warner Bros. didn’t trust
a western to be just a western (because of the relentless need to market to
teens). Screw the comic book fans, screw the western fans. Unsurprisingly, the
result is a mess that appeals to know one at all, outside the hardcore Megan
Fox boob-watchers, of course.
So why bother making the movie in the first place?
-Dave Alexander