The MacGruber Verdict
Apparently no amount of paper clips, sticks of gum and dental floss (or jokes about those kinds of things) can defeat the bad reputation of Saturday Night Live movies. MacGruber almost fell out of the top ten on its second weekend, not even yet recouping its tiny $10 million budget. I’d been hemming and hawing over whether or not to see it, weighing its box office floppiness against some positive reviews and my nostalgia for MacGyver (scroll down to the previous post), but the desire to escape this blast furnace shaped like an apartment made the decision easy, so I was one of the two dozen folks in the theatre who paid to see MacGruber on Saturday night.
The verdict?
I find in favour of MacGruber and lament the fact that it hasn’t found an audience. It’s a ballsy comedy that crosses the good taste line in some unexpected, laugh-out-loud ways, yet it doesn’t only rely on scatological humour and obvious parody (Austin Powers is guilty of this). It rips on almost every cliché of the action genre, particularly with a gag involving building the perfect team for the mission, and another one centered around taking the hero-haunted-by-his-dead-wife thing to a laugh-out-loud crescendo that winds up with a naked MacGruber in a graveyard.
Will Forte has some great moments as the mulleted titled character, taking him to disturbing levels of desperation, ineptitude and vengefulness. Ryan Phillipe is perfectly cast as the straight man, Lt. Dixon Piper; Val Kilmer and his extra chin gets a few laughs of his own, as evil mastermind Dieter Von Cunth; and the always hilarious Kristen Wiig, as Vicki St. Elmo, gets to play a love interest that actually gets laughs on her own – mainly though her reactions to being forced into dangerous situations.
That said, Mac Gruber isn’t quite a classic. There are a lot of missed opportunities with the impromptu gadgets, weapons and traps thing, it relies too much on the characters being anachronisms (for example, the dated mullet humour is supposed to be funny just ‘cause) and the roles could have been better written. Like almost every SNL movie, MacGruber will go for a gag even if it doesn’t ring true for the character; MacGruber himself is apparently “the best that there is” yet it seems obvious to even the other characters that he’s a cowardly moron, yet, later on, we see that he’s also a total savage who loves to rip throats out.
Those problems aside, the movie is a lot more hit than miss and deserves support if you’re into comedies that aren’t afraid to “take it there.” There wasn’t a big crowd at the screening I attended, but the film had won us over and there was cheering and enthusiastic laughter.
So why is it failing?
I’d say that the main reason is the bad rep of SNL films, but also the MacGyver parody concept is too old to appeal to the Scary Movie crowd, and that boring poster (again, scroll down) is a dud. Definitely not problems you can fix with duct tape, cigarette butts and some gummy bears.
-Dave Alexander
