Well, there are no tribbles in it, so it can't be a perfect Trek experience... but the new Star Trek is still a helluva voyage for Trekkers, casual fans and newbies alike. You don't have to take my word for it, though.
In March I enlisted the three biggest Star Trek fans that I know to speculate on
J.J. Abram’s fresh take on the movie franchise – based on what they could glean
from the trailer. (Read their comments here.)
This past weekend we went together to see the new movie, and I asked
them to give me their thoughts on it now. We were roundly surprised at how good it
is, on almost every level. I’ve interviewed the members of our away-team below to discuss the finer
points of an experience we’ll call…The Trekkening!
But before we get started, I’ve reposted their pics and
stats, so you can get acquainted, or reacquainted, with our team of Trek specialists.
Meet the landing party:
Name: Colin
Occupation: Software Consultant
Trekker cred: Watched every Star Trek series, movie, and the fan-made series Star Trek: Phase II.

Name: Justin
Occupation: Illustrator/Graphic Designer
Trekker cred: I own Star Trek: The Next Generation on DVD in its entirety, and have the TNG-era
communicator pin proudly displayed on my laptop case. I've gone to the
FanExpo here in Toronto for around eight years in a row now, and I
always make a point to meet any Trek personalities they have in attendance. In college if a Trek episode I hadn't seen before was on TV, I would skip class to watch it.
Name: Liisa
Occupation: Chief Officer of Rock Writing
Trekker Cred: Formerly known as that girl dressed up like Deanna Troi at cons. Hey, we have the same eyebrows.
And now, those questions (WARNING: SPOILERS):
Sensors indicated a
high level of enjoyment from this new Trek.
How does it rank for you?
C: It's a fun
movie and it's great if you factor in the difficulty of "let's restart Star Trek with different actors playing
iconic characters, have it tie into existing continuity, and make the film
accessible to non-Trek fans." That's
a huge minefield that they expertly navigated. Still, I would rank this one
after Wrath of Khan and Undiscovered Country (Star Trek II and VI). The new Star Trek may be more of a spectacle,
but those films have better character development and story.
J: Ensign, set
course to excitement, maximum warp. Engage!
L: Star Trek Begins (well, they could have called it that) was by far my favourite
Trek feature yet. Because of its (mostly) all new cast, the film felt
completely fresh, as opposed to merely a big-budget two-hour TV episode, like
even the best of the previous films. My main concern going in was that it would
be a straight-up action film for kids; while the two-hour running time did fly
by at warp speed from one fight scene to the next, it never felt stupid. That's
not to say it couldn't have been smarter: this is the only Abrams creation I've
watched that didn't leave me scratching my head on some level, pondering both
profound questions and mind-bending minutiae. It's clearly setting up a sequel,
which I hope will tackle more complex ideas.
I thought the film
was much funnier that I expected (for example, the guy in the red suit who goes
on the away mission). What was your biggest surprise while watching the new Trek?
C: *SPOILER* My
biggest surprise was the death of Spock's mom. She always helped Spock deal
with his human side in the original series. My second biggest surprise was how
well they balanced the supporting characters (Bones, Chekov, Sulu, Uhura, Scotty)
with the main characters of Spock and Kirk. They all had important roles in the
film.
J: I think the
biggest surprise for me was the film itself! I didn't expect to like it as much
as I did. Also, the amount of small details culled directly from previous Trek outings was extremely welcome. It
showed that while trying to capture a new audience they weren't going to ignore
the pre-existing one. Chris Pine as Kirk was also a huge surprise. I didn't
think he'd be able to do Kirk as good as he did, but he captured the character
pretty damn well.
L: I was
delighted at the screen time for Leonard Nimoy. I was expecting no more than a
cameo but his presence looms large. (Does anyone else think he resembles
Leonard Cohen a bit much these days?) Despite what the trailer suggests, Chris
Pine is much better as Kirk than I had assumed he would be; I hope he's ready
for a life-time playing the guy now. Otherwise, yes, I loved the consistent
injection of in-jokes (both dialogue and visuals), which mostly seemed targeted
directly for the Trek fans.
Who are your
favourite three characters in the film, and why?
C: 1) Kirk – intuitive,
clever, ladies man, and can handle himself in a fight. 2) McCoy – Karl Urban brings
the curmudgeon-ness and nails McCoy. 3) Chekov/Mr. Scott – tie. Both of them brought a lot of humour into the
film. I liked Chekov's excitement and
eagerness towards problem solving and although they call him "Scotty"
in the film, it's not the same personality of the Montgomery Scott that we
knew. This may have bothered me if it was anyone else playing that character,
but it's Simon Pegg doing a Scottish accent on a spaceship – how can you not
like that?
J: Karl Urban as
Dr. Leonard “Bones” McCoy is definitely up there. My first impression when
hearing he was playing Bones was something like, "You mean Eomer (Lord of the Rings) is playing Bones?!
How do you go from a Rider of Rohan to the Chief Medical Officer aboard the Enterprise?!" But he
did it really well, and needed more screen time! Bruce Greenwood as Captain
Pike was also great, because he became the father figure and inspiration that
Chris Pine's Kirk needed. Lastly, that Red Shirt that bought it trying to take
down the planet-destroying bathtub plug. It was the perfect set up of the
obligatory red shirt death! Here's this potentially crazy motherfucker that
wants to "kick Romulan ass" and that attitude is what ends up killing
him. Amazing. Never wear red in Star Trek.
L: First two are
logical: Spock and Spock. (Although calling Nimoy "Spock
Prime" has an unwelcome Transformers ring to it, doesn't it?). They look sharp and,
ironically, display the greatest range of emotion of all the characters. And
then that little alien on Delta Vega working with Mr. Scott; I hope Burger King
makes some toys of that dude.
Um, I forgot to mention that Spock is hot. Just so you know.
I already know that
you guys liked it, but let’s nitpick a bit at some of the stuff that bugged
you. For example, I don’t see how it would be so easy for an alien ship to show
up on either Earth or Vulcan with a ludicrous umbilical drilling machine and
start messing stuff up without anyone doing much about it. Shouldn’t that ship
have been under attack immediately?
C: I actually
don't think the umbilical drilling machine is ludicrous, as you would want to
be as close to a planet's surface to use it (less energy required) without
getting caught in the debris dustup, thus you’d place your ship in orbit. Also,
the Romulan ship was attacked
immediately where it appeared. We heard what happened to a fleet of Klingons
and saw what happened to a Federation fleet when the Enterprise warped to Vulcan. The Romulan ship only lowers the mining umbilical once a
planet's defenses have been wiped out. Unfortunately, we didn't get to see what
happened to Earth's defenses, leaving us to assume that Pike gave up the
defense codes and the Romulan ship eliminated them.
Other nitpicky stuff: 1) the Vulcan ship that contained the
"red matter" had the potential to create hundreds of thousands of
black holes but didn't have anyone guarding it, especially after intruders
boarded their ship (didn't it occur to them that maybe there's more intruders
and they should secure their doomsday device?). 2) Excessive lens flare and
reflections. 3) Kirk running into Spock on the ice planet, those are quite the
odds.
J: That is my
number one nitpick! So, this giant ship is going to bore a hole directly into
the planet's core, and all you're going to do is watch? It would have helped to
see Nero plow through some defenses first, but still. And only two guys
guarding the thing?
The constant lens/light flares that streak across the screen
became pretty offensive when you couldn't tell what was going on, since they
occupied the entire screen.
Finally: Winona Ryder. I really didn't buy her as Spock's
mother. If anything, she took you out of the experience, her being a name actor
amongst younger and lesser-knowns, and once again trying to have an accent. I
hate to admit it but I was glad when she died, and might have said,
"That's what you get for Dracula"
under my breath. Some of the lines they gave to Nero were a little
cringe-worthy, as well.
L: 1. Um, isn't
the Prime Directive to not interfere with the destiny of others, particularly
through introducing technology from the future? Oopsie.
2. I'd like to be transported to an alternate timeline with
so many convenient co-incidences too. Fancy Starfleet hanging around Kirk's farmtown
in Iowa,
looking for new recruits. Also handy: exiled Kirk landing not only on the
planet in which Spock is hiding but mere tumbling distance from his door.
Did the filmmakers do
a good job of tying this one into the rest of the Star Trek universe?
C: I think so,
but deciding to do a parallel time line rather than trying to maintain the
existing timeline really freed them from having to maintain established
continuity in the past.
J: Yes, and I
hope they make more!
L: It did feel
right, but mostly because of the bang-on casting, not the plot. But ultimately
that wasn't the goal was it? It was to boldly go and bring the Star Trek universe to a next generation
of audiences. I'm sure nobody, Abrams least of all, wanted to piss off the
life-time Trek fans, but since it's
their destiny to nitpick, there's no winning anyway.
When Spock takes the
elders from that temple, exactly what do you think they were doing in there?
C: They were
playing ring-around-the-statue, a Vulcan favourite for over 5000 years. Either that or they were praying, despite how
that would seemingly conflict with logic.
J: Something not
very logical!
L: I like to
think they were convening the tribal council to vote Winona Ryder out of the
movie, but that's probably just me.
Thanks to our resident Trek experts for their time. And a
final note: if you’re on the fence about seeing it for some reason, don’t wait
for DVD, as it’s a truly theatrical experience. See it in on as big a screen as
possible, in a movie theatre with a ridiculously huge sound system, because it
takes full advantage of technology and the movie itself just feels so big. In
other words, when stuff starts exploding en
masse, you’re gonna feel like you’re there (except for the shots in space,
because then you’d be very cold and unable to breathe).
OK, final, final note: I also wrote a piece for MSN about the eight best lighthearted riffs on the Star Trek universe, and you can read it here.